This IS a new shirt (of course), but it feels like an old favorite that has been washed a hundred times. One of our customers described it this way: "It's like the heel of a well-worn sock." It's thin. At some point it may even get a hole in it somewhere, but just keep on wearing it, because that's part of the appeal.
It's super-soft 100% cotton with a screen-printed logo. This is Men's sizing, but women like them, too!